As a Chairman of a Commission appointed by the Government write a Short Report on the causes of corruption prevailing in an over-staffed government office, make feasible suggestions how to eradicate this evil.
Show answerJawab dekhein
To: The Secretary, Establishment Division, Government of Pakistan From: Chairman, Commission on Corruption in the District Accounts Office Date: 15 March 2011 Subject: Report on the causes of corruption in the District Accounts Office and measures to eradicate it 1. Introduction The Government appointed this Commission on 1 January 2011 to find out why corruption prevails in the over-staffed District Accounts Office and to recommend practical remedies. The Commission examined office records, interviewed 40 employees and 60 members of the public, and compared procedures with those of two well-run offices. 2. Findings: causes of corruption a) Over-staffing: the office has 180 employees against a sanctioned need of about 110. Idle staff create unnecessary steps in each file so that they can demand "speed money". b) Low salaries and poor service conditions: pay has not kept pace with inflation, and staff justify bribes as a way to meet living costs. c) Complex manual procedures: a pension or bill file passes through up to 12 desks, and every desk is a point where payment can be demanded. d) Lack of accountability: there are no time limits for cases, no performance targets and almost no punishment; inquiries are rarely completed. e) Political and nepotistic appointments: many staff were recruited on recommendation rather than merit and feel protected. f) Lack of transparency: the public does not know the procedure, the fee or the time required, so they depend on middlemen. 3. Conclusions Corruption in the office is caused mainly by surplus, under-paid and unaccountable staff working in a complicated, non-transparent manual system. 4. Recommendations a) Right-size the office: transfer or retrain about 70 surplus employees and stop further recruitment except on merit through the Public Service Commission. b) Revise pay scales and link annual increments and promotions to performance. c) Computerize the system and set up a one-window counter with fixed time limits (e.g. pensions in 15 days) and online tracking of files. d) Display procedures, fees and time limits publicly and launch a complaint hotline. e) Rotate staff on sensitive seats every two years and conduct regular surprise audits. f) Protect whistle-blowers and ensure quick, visible punishment of corrupt officials through a fast-track inquiry cell. g) Enforce a code of conduct and require annual declaration of assets by all employees. (Signed) Chairman of the Commission